Oils spills and vivisection

Last night Kid1 stumbled across an online news story about the Gulf of Mexico oil spill and the damage done to the environment and wildlife. She was horrified. Her rant to me focussed however on the actions of the people filming the horrors.

“Why aren’t they helping the birds? They just stand there, filming. They should be washing the birds clean.”

And so began a brief discussion on what it would take to save the birds, if at all possible, versus the need to capture on film the consequences of an oil spill. It wasn’t a long discussion, but it did lead in turn to talk of her current homework assignment – an argumentative piece on vivisection. Her study on this controversial topic has created some personal turmoil for her. She understands the scientific and medical value in some cases, but cannot abide the cruelty to animals. While she doesn’t articulate it so clearly, her dilemma is the greyness between right and wrong – there is no correct answer.

In primary school, a child’s view of the world is very black and white. This is an over simplification – however, the early to mid years of primary school focus strongly on children developing a sense of what they should or should not do. The later years of primary school present children with some opportunities to analyse situations and apply their own reasoning. But as a means of encouraging this thinking process, the questions posed are not intricate nor value based. The children are taught the use of de Bono’s ‘six hats’, but it is in unconfrontational contexts. The child is guided to success by determining how the different hats may be used, rather any merit assigned to the different points of view. I have seen many reports on school excursions expressed through the ‘six hats’ – and the child will worry about using the ‘black hat’ when talking about poor camp food, or the stinky pit toilets at CERES, as there is concern in stating any negatives.

With the leap into high school this year, Kid1 is suddenly facing more complex issues, where personal values may be questioned. The vivisection essay has greatly stirred her thought processes. It’s made her question ethics versus medical value, cruelty vs scientific findings. As her mother, it’s fascinating to watch those brain cells start clicking! I can see the mental to and fro ricocheting in her mind – and I’m immensely happy.

She’s comprehending adult concepts, and with them the pain of the ‘grey areas’. While I am sad for the loss of innocence, and the easy answers, I can’t help but feel proud. One sensitive and astute young child is well on her way into the world! Perhaps we got some of that parenting stuff right?

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Oils spills and vivisection

  1. gigglesigh says:

    This is how you truly make your mark on the world – raising a child who thinks for herself! Great job mum!!

  2. strawberriesofintegrity says:

    Great post. My Ms14 just did a major sceince assignment on best ways to clean birds after an oil spill – she started it before the BP/Gulf oil spill, but was able to include some very topical, current news as well as a result.
    I love seeing them develop arguments and refine their thinking and go from black and white to grey…you sound like you have fine kids – well done!

  3. Oh yes, that is definitely part of that transition to adult thinking… the world of grey. I remember hitting it and being very uncomfortable.
    I like the 6 hats – we use them now and again at work with some things.

  4. i love that her reaction was immediately and spontaneously about saving the birds. not only are you raising an independent thinker, but you’re also raising a compassionate, caring and sensitive young woman.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s